All-Americans

2024-2025	Ryan Broeckel	Men's Basketball	First Team Academic All-America® First Team All-American Second Team All-American Fourth Team Preseason All-American	CSC D3hoops.com NABC D3hoops.com
2023-2024	Ryan Broeckel Zeke Micheel Lexi Martin	Men's Basketball Men's Outdoor Track & Field Softball	First Team All-America Second Team Academic All-America® Second Team All-America Third Team All-America Third Team Academic All-America®	NABC CSC USTFCCCA NFCA CSC
2022-2023	Puma Galvan Ryan Broeckel Lexi Martin	Men's Soccer Men's Basketball Softball	Third Team All-American Third Team All-America First Team All-America	United Soccer Coaches NABC NFCA
2021-2022	Kendra Schumacher	Women's Outdoor Track & Field Women's Indoor Track & Field	All-America	USTFCCCA
2018-2019	Jen Dowden	Women's Basketball	Second Team Preseason All-American	D3hoops.com
2017-2018	Jen Dowden	Women's Basketball	Second Team All-American	D3hoops.com
2014-2015	Kristen Schulz	Women's Basketball	First Team All-American All-America First Team Third Team All-American Third Team Academic All-America® All-America Honorable Mention	D3hoops.com BennettRank DIII News Capital One WBCA
2006-2007	Chris Glasel	Baseball	Honorable Mention All-American	D3baseball.com
2002-2003	Julie Christensen	Women's Basketball	First Team Academic All-America®	Verizon
2000-2001	Josh Metzger Sara Zondag	Men's Basketball Women's Basketball	Fourth Team All-American First Team All-American	NCAA Division III Lutheran Brotherhood
1999-2000	Josh Metzger Sara Zondag	Men's Basketball Women's Basketball	Third Team All-American First Team All-American First Team All-American	NCAA Division III Lutheran Brotherhood Lutheran Brotherhood
1996-1997	Scott Frey	Men's Basketball	Honorable Mention All-American	NAIA
1995-1996	Kon Knueppel	Men's Basketball	Second Team All-American	NAIA
1992-1993	Paula Stelter	Volleyball	Third Team All-American	NAIA
1991-1992	Paula Stelter Renee Kietzmann	Volleyball Softball	Third Team All-American Second Team All-American	NAIA NAIA