The Roger Fleming Senior Scholar-Athlete Award is presented to a graduating senior who over seven semesters has maintained a cumulative grade point average of at least 3.4, earned a minimum of two varsity letters in a specific sport, and demonstrated Christian leadership on campus.

2025: Isaiah Herried, Ali Schmidt
2024: Ryan Broeckel, Lexi Martin
2023: Jenna Charron, Trevor Stiede
2022: Jenna Mace, Sam Rodmyre
2021: Johnny Kositzky Jr., Kendra Schumacher
2020: Colin Biesterfeld, Melissa Ericson
2019: Damon Gnewikow, Britley Grulke
2018: Cassie Balts, JD Leisemann
2017: Jacob Jodat, Carly Warner
2016: Tanner Behnke, Karisa Pedersen 
2015: Jenny Ebeling, Luke Sebald
2014: Erin Greenfield, Eric Zeitler
2013: Kathryn Hendee, Tyler Schoen
2012: Alex Merbach, Jenna Neuberger
2011: Erika Laete
2010: Alex Allister, Whitney Miller
2009: Danny Behm
2008: Emily Laete, Beth Windschitl
2007: Emily Henrich
2006: Jill Huebner
2005: Erin Hilleshiem, Adam Markham
2004: Rebekah Himm
2003: Carrie Ogonowski
2002: Melissa Boehm
2001: Stacey Bondow, Aaron Wiechmann
2000: Lisa Vallesky
1999: David Micheel
1998: Christine Anderson
1997: Paula Brauer
1996: Dave Ross
1995: Mike Festerling, Ann Sonnabend
1993: Dave Reinemann
1992: Renee Kietzmann, Kole Knueppel
1991: Jim Bilitz, Julie Rardin
1990: Ruth Malchow, Mark Ross
1989: Jackie Schepp