Abby (Mahsem) Davis is one of the most decorated student-athletes in Wisconsin Lutheran College softball history. A dominant two-way player, Davis made her mark both in the circle and at the plate during her four-year career (2016–2019) with the Warriors. She was a two-time NFCA Second Team All-Region selection, the Northern Athletics Collegiate Conference Pitcher of the Year in both 2018 and 2019, and a three-time All-NACC honoree. Davis led the conference in strikeouts in consecutive seasons, fanning 169 batters in 2018 and 154 in 2019, while also pacing the league with a 1.81 ERA her senior year. She threw the first perfect game in program history on April 7, 2019, in a 12-0 five-inning shutout over Edgewood. Davis graduated as the Warriors' all-time leader in at-bats (469), hits (165), doubles (36), and RBI (82), while finishing her career ranked second in program history in strikeouts (481), shutouts (14), and ERA (2.40). The South Milwaukee, Wisconsin, native was named NACC Student-Athlete of the Week three times and earned NACC Scholar-Athlete recognition all four years.